
Topp Twins: Untouchable Girls (2009)
Dir: Leanne Pooley
They are an act, says one participant in this documentary, that shouldn’t work on paper: a pair of yodeling lesbian twins who sing country music. But they do, and have, for nearly three decades now.
This film is about the lives and times of one of New Zealand’s most famous and entertaining acts. A unique blend of busking, queerified country, broad character comedy, improv, good old-fashioned entertainment and an endearing yarn or three, “Untouchable Girls” reminds us of the fabulous national treasures that are Lynda and Jools Topp.
I’m gushing, I know, but it’s that kind of film. One reviewer described it as moving, and I expected that this would be in reference to Jools’ recent battle with breast cancer. While this is referenced and shown, effects of chemotherapy and all, it’s the playing out of politically historic moments of the last twenty years and the duo’s staunch and visible support of various causes that also brings a tear to the eye: Maori land rights, the Springbok tour protests, and homosexual law reform.
I was 8 years old when the Homosexual Law Reform Bill passed in 1986. The debate leading up to it was divisive and nasty, characterized by MPs such as National’s Norm Jones screaming at gay protesters to get back to the sewers where they belonged.
In this sort of environment, it is extraordinary that the Topps were not only out and proud, but a successful, mainstream act at the same time. They sang love songs about women and told lesbian jokes in their acts. The careers of many other local gay entertainers of the period, such as cooking couple Hudson and Halls, operated strictly on a don’t ask, don’t tell basis – a strategy which some modern personalities and performers continue to employ.
These are country girls, who grew up working on the farm with their dad, and still eschew city life for the rural lifestyle today. They’ve played gigs all over the world, but they still say nothing beats an A&P show. They’re born of archetypal New Zild parents – farmer dad, housewife mum. They also have a gay brother (there goes that gay gene argument again).
“Untouchable Girls” follows the Topps as they perform around the world, around New Zealand, on streets, in theatres and on television, using archive footage from the last twenty years, as well as interviews with those nearest and dearest to them, their parents and partners, as well as admirers such as songwriter Don McGlashan and former Prime Minister Helen Clark.
Beautifully filmed and edited, it depicts a New Zealand that I’m still not sure actually exists, particularly when recounting a Gypsy Caravan tour they undertook in the 1980s, traveling from small town to small town to play gigs in community halls, traveling in a caravan with a top speed of 15mph on a good day.
This is a New Zealand from the romantic fantasy “Big Eden”, with its inclusiveness and accepting nature in full bloom. Perhaps it only exists when the Topp Twins come to town, but one can’t help but think that they leave a lot of magic behind after they’re gone.
PS. I viewed this on the plane to Toronto, hence the title. Thank god for on demand entertainment. Trailer here.